All Available Ohio Medicare Supplement Companies  – Should be your first stop in your search!

Our goal is to simplify the process for you.

There are 50+ medicare supplement (medigap) companies. Here is the most current complete list (pg.24 of above Guide): 


AARP / United Healthcare *G* 1-800-523-5800

Admiral Life 1-800-232-0102

American Continental 1-800-264-4000  


American National Life / TX *G* 1-800-899-6503

American Pioneer Life 1-800-538-1053

American Republic 1-888-755-3065  


Anthem BC/BS 1-888-641-5224

Assured Life Association 1-877-223-3666

Bankers Fidelity Life 1-866-458-7500

Bankers Life & Casualty 1-800-621-3724

Central Reserve Life 1-866-459-4272

Combined of America 1-800-544-5513

Conseco 1-800-541-2254

Constitution Life 1-800-789-6364

Continental General 1-866-459-4272

Equitable Life & Casualty 1-800-352-5124

Globe Life & Accident 1-800-801-6831

Golden Rule 1-800-474-4467

Great American Life 1-800-880-2745

Guarantee Trust Life 1-800-338-7452

Humana 1-888-310-8482

KSKJ Life 1-866-671-5755

Loyal American Life 1-800-633-6752

Marquette National Life 1-800-934-8203 


Medical Mutual 1-800-722-7331

Menonite Mutual Aid Assoc. # 1-800-348-7468 


National States 1-800-868-6788

Paramount 1-888-891-0707 


Pennsylvania Life 1-800-275-7366

Philadelphia American Life 1-877-368-4691  


Physicians Life 1-800-228-9100

Provident American L & H 1-866-459-4272  

Reserve National 1-800-654-9106

Royal Neighbors of America  1-866-845-6665 

Standard Life & Accident 1-888-350-1488

State Farm Mutual Auto Call a local agent

State Mutual 1-877-777-2443

Sterling Investors Life 1-800-232-0102 

Sterling Life ^^ 1-888-858-8544

Summa 1-888-464-8440

The Health Plan 1-877-236-2290

Thrivent Fin. for Lutherans # 1-800-847-4836

United American 1-800-331-2512

United Commercial Travelers # 1-800-848-0123

United of Omaha 1-800-865-2674 

United Teachers Assocs. 1-800-880-8824

USAA Life 1-800-531-8722

Also available “2010” are Gerber Life and GPM -Government Personnel Mutual. 

Please keep in mind that companies in the medicare supplement market often “adjust” rates every few years. This is exactly the reason that we make great efforts to contract with the most affordable carriers in the state at all times.

 To better serve our clients we simply have more available options! If one company has a huge increase in premium, we simply move to another. This is becoming extremely popular with our clients, especially since some plans are becoming “Guaranteed Issued” with the Modernized 2010 Medigap/Medicare Supplement Plans. 

Call or click for Details!

1-888-769-1981 (toll free)

Ed Hill